The Unforeseen Problem with Insta Followers
Why pedophiles and sex traffickers are loving social media
It’s by far the biggest problem with social media right now…and I don’t think Instagram or YouTube ever saw it coming. It’s affecting the online safety of our kids and creating a pressurized environment that’s wreaking havoc on their mental health. It’s that little number on the top center of your Instagram account.
On YouTube it’s called “subscribers.” With Snapchat it’s “friends.” And every one of these descriptors has a number attached to it… and that number is changing everything.
Here’s the thing. Nine out of ten teenagers now carry a device around in their pocket that has a real-time number telling them exactly how popular…or unpopular…they are. And if you think that kids are not influenced by that one little number…think again.
More Followers Please
When I was a kid I wanted to be Magnum P.I. Nice car, lived in Hawaii… and every girl I knew thought he was hot.
My friend David wanted to be Michael Jordan.
But now young people’s eyes are set on a different horizon.
Ypulse research just conducted a survey revealing that 72% of Gen Z (age 24 and below) would like to be an online celeb (compared to 55% of Millennials), emphasis on the word “online.” We’re not talking about Will Smith or Ariana Grande, we’re talking about David Dobrick, Emma Chamberlain or PewDiePie. You may not recognize these names, but your kids do. These are all individuals whose YouTube or Instagram pages launched them to fame (and fortune).
Seven in ten young people want that. They don’t want to be a doctor, a lawyer, a fireman…or a private investigator in Hawaii… they want to be an Instaceleb. And because of this, seven in ten young people feel the need to attract more followers (and the other three want them too). Followers convey value.
“How many followers do you have?”
“746. But Christina has 1249.”
Christina must be more valuable than me.
Consider how this “lens” is affecting the way young people view their world.
This churning desire for followers has birthed two unanticipated dangers: one in the area of online safety, and the other in the area of mental health.
Let’s take a closer look at each:
1. Stranger Friends
The concept of “don’t talk to strangers” is soooooooo yesterday. Now strangers are merely potential followers.
You have a friend request.
“Cool, this nice guy named Ted Bundy wants to follow me! Yasssss!”
Anything that makes that number of followers go up is good, right?
Let this whole paradigm sink in for a moment. Today’s young people aren’t worried about “privacy” anymore. They either have switched their accounts to public (so anyone can follow) or they are saying yes to as many people as possible.
What does this mean for online safety?
It means that most young people today have “followers” who aren’t who they seem.
Last week I was talking to kids in public school assemblies about this dilemma. In preparation for the assemblies I scanned the school’s Instagram account, found student profiles linked to the school and began clicking and scrolling through some of the profiles. The overwhelming majority were public, so anyone could view them. Not surprising, many of the girls posted pics a little too revealing.
Here’s where it got a little bit scary: if you looked at the comments on many of those posts, you’d find responses from “modeling agencies” who requested the student to DM (direct message) them. I “shared” some of these profiles to a contact I know in the LAPD Human Trafficking Unit, and she told me that these “modeling” agencies are rarely who they say they are. In fact, the majority of sex crimes involving the internet begin just like this—predators on social media posing as someone they’re not.
And these were just typical Insta profiles at an ordinary high school in small town Kansas.
It’s happening more frequently than you want to know about, especially with vulnerable girls who are looking for love outside their current home environment.
Three weeks ago I was at my doctor’s office and the nurse asked me what I did for a living. I told her I was an author and most of my speaking right now was to parents and schools about teens and screens. As I told her a little bit about the struggles principals and school administrators were having, especially in the area of girls regretting sharing revealing pics… this nurse’s eyes began to tear up.
“You know someone who this happened to, don’t you?” I asked.
“My niece.” She said, wiping a tear from her cheek. “When she was in foster care she met a teenage guy online, one thing led to another and she snuck out to meet him…
He wasn’t a teenager at all. She was trafficked to Vegas.”
I wish it was the only time I heard stories like this.
Literally every time I speak about this in some random city across the U.S. someone will come up to me and share their firsthand experience of their son or daughter meeting a guy online, building a relationship, only to eventually discover it wasn’t who they thought it was. Often these stories have horrifying endings.
And rural towns are not immune from this. Last week when I spoke on this subject in “nowhere” North Dakota, a youth leader approached me when I was finished speaking and told me one of their biggest struggles on their youth trips was that their teenagers wanted to sneak out and meet up with “strangers” they had met on Instagram.
What’s the solution?
Here’s several safety precautions parents can practice:
- First and foremost, talk about these realities with your kids. Don’t just hand your kids a phone—make them prove they understand how to use it responsibly. Make them go through a book like The Teen’s Guide to Social Media & Mobile Devices with you and learn what wise posting looks like in an insecure world.
- Teach your kids how to recognize predatory behavior. Read articles together about the links between social media and sex trafficking. Reinforce habits like never posting or sharing personal information, never posting locations near your house, and absolutely never meeting strangers in person…unless you bring the entire defensive line of your high school football team with you!
- Teach them (or in many cases, learn with them) about specific location and privacy settings. Like in Snapchat, for example: did they opt in to Snap Maps? If so, did they choose to share their location with all their friends (so all their friends, including Ted Bundy can see exactly where they are on a map?) or with “only these friends” and choose specific friends they trust? Help them think through the ramifications if they are “friending” people they haven’t met face-to-face.
- Set helpful screen limits like, “no phones in the bedroom at night.” Simple screen limits like these cut down on the chances of kids making bad late-night decisions.
But online safety isn’t the only unwelcomed product of the desire for more followers…
2. Not As Many As Her
I met a girl who had more Instagram followers than anyone in her school, but still seemed distressed about the size of the number.
“What’s wrong?” I asked. “Looks like you’ve got a lot of friends.”
“Yeah,” she sighed. “But not as much as Kylie Jenner.”
Kylie Jenner is a self-made billionaire with 141 million Instagram followers.
the overwhelming majority of young people are constantly being reminded what fame and fortune looks like…and that they don’t have it.
Perhaps that’s why we’re seeing an unprecedented spike in teen anxiety, depression and even suicide in teenagers today.
Social Media giants like Instagram have recognized the effect these apps can have on the mental health of young people. In fact, Insta is testing a feature in 7 different countries that will hide from your followers the number of “likes” you receive, hoping to create “a less pressurized environment where people feel comfortable expressing themselves.”
Time will tell. If only they’d do the same with the number of followers.
So what can parents do to help their kids avoid these self-inflicted feelings that they just don’t measure up? Here’s a few ways to build into the self-esteem of generation screen:
- Be on the lookout for opportunities where you can engage your kids in face-to-face conversation in an otherwise screen-to-screen world. A 2018 survey revealed that almost 70 percent of teenagers admitted that they wish they could spend more time “socializing face-to-face” than online.
- Again, set helpful screen limits so your kids aren’t getting sucked into the drama for hours upon hours each day. In fact, earlier this year Mental Health advocate Jean Twenge cited, four large studies of teenagers all showing the same thing: “happiness and mental health are highest at a half-hour to two hours of extracurricular digital media use a day.” Consider what that might look like in your home.
- Most social media requires kids are at least 13-years-old, so use that and delay social media until they’re old enough. Your 11-year-old doesn’t need to be navigating the streets of social media before then. The answer isn’t no, it’s “not yet.”
- In a world so potent with lies, don’t forget to raise your kids in the truth. Sometimes moms and dads become so focused on blocking out the bad they forget to simply focus on the good. Don’t be so concerned about finding the perfect porn filter that you neglect just sitting down and talking with your kids about God’s design for sex. Get your kids into the word of God. The more time they spend in the truth, the better equipped they’ll be to recognize lies.
If your kid wants to be the next PewDiePie, you don’t need to crush his dreams. But remember, if your kid wanted to be a Nascar driver, you probably wouldn’t let him start driving at 12-years-old. Same is true with that device in their pocket. Age restrictions and screen limits are very healthy, especially when balanced with a comfortable climate of continuing conversations about what wise posting looks like in an insecure world.
Are you engaging your kids in these conversations?
OR FOR MORE ON THE SUBJECT OF SOCIAL MEDIA, SCREEN TIME AND THE PRESSURE TO BE LIKED, TAKE A PEEK AT JONATHAN McKEE’S EXTREMELY HELPFUL BOOK, THE TEEN’S GUIDE TO SOCIAL MEDIA & MOBILE DEVICES
WANT TO INTERACT WITH JONATHAN PERSONALLY ABOUT TEENS AND SCREENS? BOOK JONATHAN’S ZOOM WORKSHOP NOW FOR YOUR CHURCH, SCHOOL OR ORGANIZATION!
Jonathan McKee is the author of over twenty books including the brand new The Guy's Guide to FOUR BATTLES Every Young Man Must Face; The Teen’s Guide to Social Media & Mobile Devices; If I Had a Parenting Do Over; and the Amazon Best Seller - The Guy's Guide to God, Girls and the Phone in Your Pocket. He speaks to parents and leaders worldwide, all while providing free resources for parents on his website TheSource4Parents.com. Jonathan, his wife Lori, and their three kids live in California.